December 21, 2005


Dear Fr. O'Malley,

Thank you for your response to the package of papers I sent to you last week. In your response you asked me how I "reconcile obedience to the teaching authority of The Church, with your (my) continued adherence to & support of something which The Cardinal & Pope said never happened".

I must remind you that there is NO disobedience whatsoever involved here. The decree signed by the cardinal and ratified by then Cardinal Ratzinger simply stated there was no proof of the supernatural, Constat De Non Supernaturalitate. Officially Medjugorje is in the same exact state. Contrary to what some people would like to believe and promote, the apparitions of Our Lady in Emmitsburg have not been condemned. Additionally, by church law they can't be without a valid proof of fraud or demonic origin.

Lastly, the papers I have provided to you are a true and accurate eyewitness report as I have witnessed it since 1998. Since I know with 100% certainty that I have told nothing but the truth I am at complete peace with it. I hope this answers your question.

I wish you a merry Christmas,


R_____ C___

Dec. 21, 2005

2:33 Pm